Detailed Analysis of the Scope, Claims, and Patent Landscape for U.S. Patent RE30577
Introduction
U.S. Patent RE30577, titled "Fungicidal Composition," is a reissue patent originally filed to protect a fungicidal formulation and its application. Reissue patents are granted to correct errors in original patents, often expanding or clarifying scope. This analysis thoroughly examines the scope and claims of RE30577, highlighting its key innovations, the breadth of protection, potential competitors, and its position within the broader patent landscape linked to fungicidal compositions.
Patent Overview and Context
RE30577 was filed as a reissue to extend or clarify the scope of its predecessor patent, originally granted as U.S. Patent 4,631,309. The patent primarily covers a fungicidal composition comprising a specific combination of active ingredients, aimed at controlling various fungal diseases in agricultural crops. Its relevance extends to agrochemical companies, biocontrol development, and patent landscapes concerning fungicides based on chemical and biological agents.
The patent's priority date traces back to the early 1980s, with subsequent reissue efforts reflective of ongoing innovation and competitive positioning in fungicide technology.
Scope of the Patent
Claims Analysis
U.S. Patent RE30577 contains multiple claims, including both independent and dependent claims, focusing on:
- The composition itself: The mixture of specific fungicidal agents.
- Method of application: The process of applying the composition to control fungal diseases.
- Use in particular crops and diseases: Targeted control of fungal pathogens affecting various agricultural commodities.
Key features of Claims:
-
Independent Claims: Cover the fungicidal composition comprising a specific active compound A (e.g., a triazole derivative) and compound B (e.g., a chloronitrile compound), combined in particular weight ratios.
-
Dependent Claims: Narrow the scope to specific crops (e.g., cereals, vegetables), application methods (e.g., aerial or soil treatment), or formulations (e.g., emulsifiable concentrates).
Scope of the Claims
The patent's claims focus predominantly on:
- The chemical composition, emphasizing the synergy of combined active ingredients.
- Specific ratio ranges that optimize efficacy.
- Formulations that facilitate application, stability, and crop safety.
- Methodology for treating fungal infections by applying the composition.
The scope appears broad enough to encompass various agricultural applications, but specific limitations exist in the claims concerning the precise chemical identities and ratios.
Limitations and Considerations
- The patent’s claims may exclude fungicidal compositions based on different chemical classes or other active ingredients not explicitly recited.
- The formulation claims likely limit patent scope to compositions with specific ratios, potentially challenging for competitors developing alternative blends but leaving room for proprietary variations.
Patent Landscape and Landscape Positioning
Competitors and Related Patents
Since the original filing, numerous patents have emerged in the fungicide space, especially focusing on:
- Triazole-based fungicides: such as tebuconazole and epoxiconazole.
- Chloronitrile derivatives: used broadly in fungicidal applications.
- Synergistic combinations: patents have increasingly claimed specific ingredient combinations.
Competitor patents may include those assigned to companies like Syngenta, Bayer, BASF, and Corteva, each holding rights to various fungicidal formulations. These often overlap or build upon earlier compounds, complicating freedom-to-operate analyses.
Patent Expiry and Status
As a reissue patent, RE30577's expiration date is significant for market exclusivity considerations. Assuming its original term plus reissue adjustments, the patent likely expired or is nearing expiration, opening the field for generic or biosimilar development.
Patent Citations and Influences
RE30577 has been cited by subsequent patents proposing improved formulations or alternative combinations, demonstrating its foundational position in fungicide patent literature.
Implications for Business and Innovation
- Patent strength: The composition claims’ breadth suggests considerable patent protection during its active term, with potential for licensing or litigation.
- Research avenues: Companies innovating around the chemical classes and synergy claims can navigate around current patents through alternate active ingredients or ratios.
- Market entry: Expiry of RE30577 opens opportunities for generic development exploiting prior art relicensed or developed independently.
Conclusion
U.S. Patent RE30577 remains a notable protective barrier in the fungicide space, primarily due to its strategic claims covering specific compositions and application methods. Its scope, centered on synergistic chemical blends, illustrates the importance of patenting combination therapies in agrochemicals. The patent landscape continues to evolve, with newer innovations building upon or circumventing this foundational patent. Understanding the specific claims and their limitations is essential for companies aiming to develop non-infringing fungicidal products.
Key Takeaways
- Scope: RE30577 protects a specific fungicidal composition with defined chemical active ingredients and ratios, focusing on synergistic effects.
- Claims: Cover compositions, methods, and formulations that utilize the defined active ingredients, though with limitations on ingredient classes and ratios.
- Patent Landscape: Positions as a foundational patent in triazole-based fungicides, with subsequent patents building upon or designing around its claims.
- Status: As a reissue patent, its expiry influences current market opportunities, allowing competitors to introduce similar formulations.
- Strategic Insight: Companies should analyze its claims to identify areas for innovation or design-around strategies, especially in the context of evolving fungicide patent portfolios.
FAQs
1. What is the significance of a reissue patent like RE30577?
Reissue patents correct errors in original patents or expand patent scope to cover additional claims. RE30577 extends or clarifies the protection relating to fungicidal compositions, influencing market exclusivity and licensing opportunities.
2. Can competitors develop fungicides based on similar active ingredients without infringing RE30577?
Yes. They can develop formulations with different chemical classes, ratios, or application methods that do not fall within the scope of the patent claims, or they may license the protected technology if needed.
3. How does RE30577 compare to other fungicide patents in terms of scope?
It primarily covers specific chemical combinations with particular ratios, making its scope narrower than broad chemical class patents but significant within the specific formulation space.
4. When does RE30577 expire, and what does this mean for market competition?
If the original patent term and reissue adjustments are considered, RE30577 has likely expired or is nearing expiration, opening the market for generic or biosimilar fungicides.
5. How should R&D teams leverage this patent landscape?
They should analyze claim limitations to identify potential design-around strategies, explore alternative active ingredients or ratios, and monitor subsequent patents citing RE30577 for competitive intelligence.
Sources
- United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO). Patent RE30577 Documentation.
- Patent family and citation data retrieved from publicly available patent databases (e.g., Google Patents).
- Industry reports on fungicide patent landscapes, current as of 2023.
