Litigation Details for Cirba Inc. v. VMware, Inc. (D. Del. 2019)

Cirba Inc. v. VMware, Inc. (D. Del. 2019)

Docket		Date Filed	2019-04-25
Court	District Court, D. Delaware	Date Terminated
Cause	35:1 Patent Infringement	Assigned To	Leonard Philip Stark
Jury Demand	Plaintiff	Referred To
Parties	CIRBA INC.; CIRBA IP, INC.; VMWARE, INC.
Patents	10,004,742; 10,004,745; 10,004,750; 10,010,568; 10,016,415; 10,029,011; 10,064,813; 10,085,997; 10,093,732; 10,099,996; 10,131,907; 10,143,697; 10,143,723; 10,143,731; 10,143,742; 10,143,755; 10,143,756; 10,143,905; 10,149,904; 10,155,801; 10,172,802; 10,182,591; 10,189,818; 10,189,837; 10,214,540; 10,214,590; 10,214,732; 10,244,765; 10,278,415; 10,278,920; 10,278,935; 10,342,646; 10,342,764; 10,342,813; 10,342,938; 10,351,517; 10,358,453; 10,358,653; 10,358,680; 10,376,580; 10,376,584; 10,376,587; 10,376,588; 10,376,595; 10,376,658; 10,379,975; 10,415,014; 10,456,645; 10,456,646; 10,456,653; 10,463,742; 10,492,723; 10,499,636; 10,501,773; 10,517,850; 10,519,164; 10,519,228; 10,519,252; 10,526,594; 10,526,631; 10,526,656; 10,526,657; 10,543,186; 10,543,273; 10,548,876; 10,568,568; 10,570,202; 10,584,169; 10,588,886; 10,588,975; 10,590,143; 10,590,182; 10,590,185; 10,604,806; 10,617,667; 10,617,742; 10,617,755; 10,617,756; 10,617,813; 10,618,935; 10,618,967; 10,618,971; 10,624,814; 10,624,884; 6,071,706; 6,156,372; 6,156,742; 6,231,849; 6,268,010; 6,268,343; 6,302,813; 6,302,897; 6,338,687; 6,342,657; 6,395,767; 6,468,576; 6,503,754; 6,503,894; 6,505,597; 6,544,750; 6,582,654; 6,590,078; 6,620,585; 6,638,542; 6,649,597; 6,649,905; 6,653,530; 6,656,935; 6,663,107; 6,663,517; 6,663,849; 6,663,880; 6,669,584; 6,692,367; 6,692,630; 6,692,789; 6,702,850; 6,706,681; 6,720,453; 6,730,139; 6,736,302; 6,750,019; 6,773,720; 6,774,122; 6,775,887; 6,837,907; 6,838,093; 6,838,252; 6,844,152; 6,872,397; 6,872,701; 6,905,886; 6,941,326; 6,976,647; 7,041,017; 7,060,687; 7,105,730; 7,111,730; 7,115,663; 7,115,707; 7,122,372; 7,122,592; 7,128,667; 7,128,894; 7,135,624; 7,147,779; 7,149,631; 7,157,584; 7,169,791; 7,186,732; 7,214,804; 7,217,510; 7,217,519; 7,232,818; 7,232,935; 7,241,907; 7,244,571; 7,244,591; 7,244,757; 7,261,654; 7,270,813; 7,326,708; 7,331,885; 7,351,691; 7,351,701; 7,351,813; 7,425,326; 7,427,622; 7,427,638; 7,427,698; 7,456,219; 7,465,587; 7,465,756; 7,468,372; 7,476,780; 7,491,692; 7,510,584; 7,517,519; 7,540,813; 7,541,363; 7,544,698; 7,575,526; 7,575,742; 7,582,658; 7,582,694; 7,585,897; 7,589,102; 7,589,124; 7,589,193; 7,592,167; 7,592,467; 7,593,397; 7,608,261; 7,608,723; 7,608,756; 7,618,996; 7,622,592; 7,622,632; 7,622,636; 7,622,658; 7,628,996; 7,629,342; 7,629,345; 7,637,260; 7,638,620; 7,642,268; 7,645,425; 7,645,588; 7,647,468; 7,648,698; 7,667,044; 7,667,091; 7,682,642; 7,687,060; 7,687,075; 7,691,584; 7,709,022; 7,709,517; 7,723,573; 7,732,135; 7,732,162; 7,745,571; 7,767,656; 7,767,657; 7,767,687; 7,776,838; 7,776,844; 7,807,135; 7,807,167; 7,807,370; 7,807,618; 7,807,681; 7,807,708; 7,807,804; 7,818,100; 7,850,554; 7,884,263; 7,884,264; 7,886,697; 7,887,844; 7,897,363; 7,897,585; 7,897,588; 7,897,850; 7,907,135; 7,935,121; 7,935,372; 7,935,687; 7,951,589; 7,951,766; 7,976,199; 7,976,886; 7,994,129; 8,013,113; 8,092,996; 8,101,663; 8,101,818; 8,105,618; 8,121,712; 8,128,589; 8,143,425; 8,158,590; 8,178,519; 8,178,554; 8,182,838; 8,192,756; 8,222,010; 8,241,849; 8,252,589; 8,252,776; 8,252,801; 8,252,813; 8,252,838; 8,263,647; 8,268,008; 8,268,316; 8,268,348; 8,268,791; 8,268,804; 8,273,526; 8,273,789; 8,278,492; 8,287,897; 8,287,905; 8,287,940; 8,323,692; 8,323,884; 8,324,439; 8,327,844; 8,338,100; 8,343,776; 8,367,415; 8,367,649; 8,367,657; 8,367,701; 8,367,732; 8,372,624; 8,372,872; 8,394,367; 8,394,372; 8,394,463; 8,394,765; 8,415,332; 8,415,348; 8,425,462; 8,425,880; 8,425,938; 8,460,663; 8,491,882; 8,491,940; 8,501,712; 8,501,818; 8,517,631; 8,530,498; 8,541,044; 8,545,884; 8,546,608; 8,546,645; 8,563,608; 8,563,688; 8,563,692; 8,563,698; 8,568,747; 8,574,568; 8,574,575; 8,580,323; 8,580,723; 8,580,765; 8,586,630; 8,589,182; 8,591,885; 8,591,897; 8,591,938; 8,592,149; 8,592,156; 8,592,462; 8,592,644; 8,592,649; 8,597,143; 8,597,632; 8,597,654; 8,608,698; 8,609,701; 8,609,722; 8,617,100; 8,617,543; 8,617,554; 8,617,591; 8,617,593; 8,617,594; 8,617,595; 8,617,597; 8,617,876; 8,623,591; 8,623,818; 8,623,830; 8,628,724; 8,628,754; 8,632,773; 8,636,813; 8,637,457; 8,658,573; 8,658,608; 8,663,155; 8,663,617; 8,663,628; 8,663,657; 8,663,681; 8,669,227; 8,669,290; 8,691,185; 8,691,231; 8,697,193; 8,697,618; 8,697,747; 8,708,592; 8,709,081; 8,709,107; 8,709,519; 8,722,657; 8,742,185; 8,747,894; 8,747,897; 8,754,194; 8,765,167; 8,765,169; 8,765,172; 8,765,189; 8,765,421; 8,778,302; 8,778,394; 8,778,997; 8,814,920; 8,843,356; 8,888,614; 8,935,994; 8,940,302; 8,940,330; 8,940,487; 8,940,698; 8,940,766; 8,940,780; 8,940,876; 8,951,722; 8,951,967; 8,951,994; 8,951,996; 8,975,270; 8,975,457; 9,023,401; 9,023,807; 9,034,300; 9,050,302; 9,072,813; 9,078,838; 9,079,905; 9,085,709; 9,095,706; 9,096,681; 9,096,907; 9,101,592; 9,102,742; 9,107,813; 9,107,837; 9,119,791; 9,125,804; 9,126,941; 9,145,462; 9,149,474; 9,149,707; 9,155,706; 9,155,730; 9,155,776; 9,193,732; 9,193,757; 9,193,791; 9,226,967; 9,258,997; 9,260,724; 9,284,367; 9,290,755; 9,295,657; 9,302,002; 9,345,724; 9,345,754; 9,345,773; 9,359,597; 9,370,802; 9,415,004; 9,415,009; 9,415,050; 9,421,278; 9,422,469; 9,422,593; 9,439,886; 9,439,907; 9,439,940; 9,468,585; 9,468,636; 9,468,747; 9,474,273; 9,474,706; 9,474,757; 9,474,779; 9,487,767; 9,487,773; 9,492,417; 9,492,443; 9,499,545; 9,499,622; 9,499,766; 9,499,850; 9,505,701; 9,505,722; 9,505,754; 9,510,511; 9,511,193; 9,517,241; 9,517,253; 9,523,691; 9,526,209; 9,526,623; 9,526,703; 9,526,707; 9,526,709; 9,526,710; 9,526,791; 9,526,844; 9,540,425; 9,545,379; 9,550,975; 9,554,574; 9,573,818; 9,574,010; 9,585,884; 9,585,920; 9,586,940; 9,586,994; 9,586,996; 9,592,193; 9,592,252; 9,592,253; 9,592,273; 9,597,345; 9,597,397; 9,597,571; 9,597,591; 9,617,302; 9,617,343; 9,617,574; 9,618,476; 9,622,971; 9,622,975; 9,623,087; 9,623,152; 9,623,189; 9,624,260; 9,624,295; 9,629,920; 9,630,930; 9,630,975; 9,630,976; 9,631,164; 9,631,193; 9,646,199; 9,649,209; 9,649,379; 9,649,456; 9,650,327; 9,650,589; 9,663,510; 9,663,523; 9,663,574; 9,663,778; 9,669,089; 9,669,096; 9,669,107; 9,669,108; 9,669,151; 9,681,646; 9,687,474; 9,687,517; 9,687,526; 9,687,568; 9,687,608; 9,687,609; 9,688,765; 9,694,149; 9,701,712; 9,701,747; 9,701,971; 9,707,155; 9,707,182; 9,707,302; 9,708,618; 9,724,323; 9,724,331; 9,724,343; 9,724,358; 9,724,380; 9,724,391; 9,724,395; 9,724,415; 9,724,657; 9,731,082; 9,731,169; 9,732,107; 9,732,145; 9,732,149; 9,732,326; 9,732,343; 9,745,500; 9,750,703; 9,750,747; 9,756,687; 9,756,834; 9,757,351; 9,757,394; 9,764,342; 9,765,147; 9,765,182; 9,765,351; 9,765,380; 9,775,838; 9,775,844; 9,775,849; 9,775,904; 9,789,125; 9,789,156; 9,789,185; 9,789,193; 9,789,210; 9,804,151; 9,814,722; 9,814,767; 9,814,780; 9,834,586; 9,834,646; 9,844,510; 9,844,574; 9,844,594; 9,849,164; 9,849,193; 9,849,199; 9,907,379; 9,907,756; 9,907,775; 9,907,780; 9,907,801; 9,907,802; 9,907,849; 9,938,331; 9,938,356; 9,975,894; 9,994,628; 9,994,814; 9,997,273
Attorneys	Adam Adler; Anne Shea Gaza; Ariel Green; Christine E. Lehman; Courtland L. Reichman; Gary J. Toman; Jaime F Cardenas-Navia; Jennifer Estremera; Joachim B. Steinberg; Julie M.K. Siegal; Kate M. Falkenstien; Kenneth Laurence Dorsney; Khue V. Hoang; Michael G. Flanigan; Paul D. Clement; Peter J. Ayers; Richard S.J. Hung; Robert M. Vrana; Samantha G. Wilson; Sarah O. Jorgensen; Seth P. Waxman; Shawna L. Ballard; Thomas G. Saunders; Wesley Lanier White; William F. Lee; Yue Li
Firms	Young, Conaway, Stargatt & Taylor LLP
Link to Docket	External link to docket

Biologic Drugs cited in Cirba Inc. v. VMware, Inc.

Details for Cirba Inc. v. VMware, Inc. (D. Del. 2019)

Date Filed	Document No.	Description	Snippet	Link To Document
2019-09-27	208	Claim Construction Chart	:7- 60 • ’687 …claims of U.S. Patent Nos. 8,209,687 (“the ’687 patent”) and 9,654,367 (“the ’367 patent”), respectively… Proposed Constructions for U.S. Patent No. 8,209,687 (’687 patent) Claim Term/Phrase …History of U.S. Patent No. 8,209,687, • ’687 Patent File History:….S. Patent No. 8,209,687 specification at • ’687 Patent: 2:27	External link to document
2020-01-10	479	Redacted Document	26:10-29:11 106 29:22-30:9 106 26:10-29:11 … 26:10-29:11 106 32:14-34:8 MIS, H, 106 26:10-29:11 … 26:10-29:11 106 35:8-10 26:10-29:11 37:10… 26:10-29:11; 30:12-20 H, 106 30… 29:4-29:10 29:11-29:17	External link to document
2020-04-24	720	Redacted Document	different from Cirba’s patent-practicing product. (See, e.g., DTX-5328 at 9:43-10:10 (Mr. Hillier stating…the rule applies. (PTX-2057 at 98-99; see also PTX-1648 at 9-10, 12 (Compute Policies also created … DTX- 4008 at 5; TT 467:10-20, 594:25-595:8 (Densify practices ’687 patent.).) Even at the PI hearing…’367 patent’s value based solely on one customer’s purchase of Densify over vROps. (Id. 1020:10-1021…Commil USA, LLC v. Cisco Sys., Inc., 813 F.3d 994, 996-97 (Fed. Cir. 2015) (reversing JMOL denial where	External link to document
2020-04-27	724	Redacted Document	rel. B.B. v. Del. Coll. Preparatory Acad., No. 16-806-CFC, 2019 WL 949204, at *5 (D. Del. Feb. 27, 2019…Opposition to Cirba's Motion for Post-Trial Relief (D.I. 604) by VMware, Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A, # …opposition to Cirba’s Motion for Post-Trial Relief (D.I. 604). Leave should be granted because (1) Cirba’s reply…25 April 2019 1:19-cv-00742-LPS 830 Patent Plaintiff District Court, D. Delaware… agree to give Cirba 100% of its profits (id. ¶¶ 10, 20-22); and (3) asserting, for the first time, that	External link to document
2020-05-01	732	Letter	On August 10, 2015, each Defendant filed a motion for summary judgment on grounds of patent invalidity…infringe U.S. Patent No. 7,631,336 (“‘336 Patent”). Id. ¶ 22. The ‘336 Patent is entitled…Mill Road | Palo Alto, CA 94304-1018 P: [phone] mofo.com | LinkedIn | Twitter Case 1:19-cv…the ’367 patent); id. at 592:4-19 (skipping 27 slides related to claim 3 of the ’687 patent). Likewise…708, Exhibit A)): 5, 12, 20-21, 25-26, 49, 61-62, 64-65, 67, 69-70, 72, 78, 80- 87,	External link to document
2020-05-04	736	Brief - Answering Brief in Opposition	Street Boston, MA 02109 [phone] [e-mail] Case 1:19-cv-00742-LPS Document 736 Filed… 25 April 2019 1:19-cv-00742-LPS 830 Patent Plaintiff District Court,… 5 Case 1:19-cv-00742-LPS Document 736 Filed 05/04/20 Page 10 of 11 PageID #: 57929 …AND DORR LLP 60 State Street Boston, MA 02109 [phone] [e-mail] … 4 May 2020 PACER Document Case 1:19-cv-00742-LPS Document 736 Filed 05/04/20 Page 1 of 11 PageID	External link to document
2020-05-08	739	Letter	statements in Densify’s closing argument. (D.I. 584.) The Court summarily denied that request as well…iTV, Inc. v. Hawaiian Telecom, Inc., No. 1:14-cv-00169-ACK-RLP (D. Haw. Dec. 8, 2015), is not relevant …25 April 2019 1:19-cv-00742-LPS 830 Patent Plaintiff District Court, D. Delaware…Circuit will not “guess at what the jury saw.” 694 F.3d 10, 32 n.16 (2012). Densify met this burden by lodging…(claim construction and summary judgment), id. at 10, in part, because the only opportunity to review	External link to document